- Throughout China, babies don't wear diapers; instead, they have no crotch in their
pants. Parents hold up their children whenever and wherever they need to relieve themselves, and they just let it all out right there. And yes, I really mean "wherever": sidewalks, streets, buses, banks, shopping centers...
- Manners and politeness here are totally different than anywhere I have visited. It goes beyond spitting in hallways of public establishments, slurping noodles, and burping loudly (which I personally find to be quite liberating); it also carries through to everyday conversation. I learned the word for "please" in my elementary Chinese course, but literally have not heard it since my arrival. In fact, I'm not exactly how to use it in context, and was told to "just forget it" because people here don't say please, anyway. Same goes for "thank you," and although my Midwestern upbringing demands that I thank everyone anyway, I have only once heard the Chinese phrase for "you're welcome."
- The book I'm reading says that Chinese are motivated primarily by shame and not by guilt. Understanding that concept has gone a long way for me in classroom management. In general, students do not feel bad for not doing their work unless they are caught, and even then only if their peers are made aware of their laziness. Test grades are almost always public information, and it is common here to publicly shame students as punishment. One high school girl who would leave class early had to stand before an auditorium filled with her peers as her truancies were explained and ridiculed. The same goes for Chinese teachers who are late to class, although supposedly I'm saved from that by being a foreigner. (Still am going to try to be on time, though...)
- There is definitely a limit to what can be publicly discussed/read. I may have already pushed some limits in my blog so I will leave it at that.
- Classes, and life in general, seem more patterned and ritualistic than at home. For example, my classes all must begin:
Me: Class begins!
Class: (standing up) Stand up!
Me: Good morning, class!
Class: Good morning, teacher!
Class: (standing up) Stand up!
Me: Good morning, class!
Class: Good morning, teacher!
A funny story relating to that: Yesterday morning I forgot my routine, and warmly greeted my students, "Good morning, class!" They stood up automatically and barked in unison, "Good morning, teacher!" I immediately realized my mistake, and tried to salvage it by saying, "Stand up!" To which the students replied hesitantly, "Stand up!" (even though they were already standing) and looked at me and each other in obvious confusion. I think I said something like "Sit down...?" and just started cracking up. Better luck next time, foreigner.
8 comments:
Hi Amber,
The best entry so far! The observation as to what motivates people - shames versus guilt - is an excellent one. Even before I read further the description of the difference between the two I recognized instantly what they would be since something similar applies to a lot of cultures. Take ET for example: shame motivates people more than guilt - although due to religion guilt plays a role. People fear the idea of being exposed and judged for doing something more than feeling bad about doing the something. School rituals and the idea of the teacher being the authority and the formality etc are similar in a lot of places too.
But we part company on things that you might define as manners. The culture in a lot of places, including in ET, demands the utmost in refinement - no burping of any kind in public and for that matter of any other bodily functions. And the idea of letting the babies go anywhere, well that is just unheard of. In addition, the p's and q's are generally well observed. As a matter of fact, if you display 'bad' manners people sorry for your family since they are being disgraced big time by your actions. And disgrace = shame.
well Amber, I enjoyed this one a lot and I hope you are doing really well!
xoxoxo
Lullit
Crotchless baby pants - and all that entails - is a bad, bad, bad idea. It reminds me of some of the earlier posts about public toilets - China seems to have some bathroom issues...(and yes I know this is judgmental/ethnocentric but come on, there's a reason it's called waste...)
i sense another market opportunity for the biff... hallmark of every distinguished society
I still can NOT believe that kids clothes don't have crotches and they just go wherever!
Amber I am loving this post, I can picture your morning routine perfectly and your inability to abide by it. You are far too spontaneous. I miss you!
Baby biff...good idea.
Hey Ambie,
I want to know who cleans up all that baby poop? Or does it just get stepped over, tracked around, or whatever.
Also, I thought the shaming was interesting. In the Minnesota schools I've taught in, shaming is definitely not an acceptable means of discipline. The current thinking is that relationships are the key to reaching students. Shaming doesn't build teacher-student relationships. Of course neither does having classrooms of 40 students. Maybe we don't really care that much.
Love,
Mom
Good question, Mom, and you're probably not the only one wondering this... Theoretically China's "street sweepers" (people who carry around witch-like brooms, as shown in my Halloween photo with Coco) should take care of the poop on the sidewalks, and cleaning staff should take care of the indoor droppings. However I have definitely seen poop on the streets/sidewalks/floor here. Sam commented during our trip to Yangshuo, "The difference between the US and China is that in America, when you see poop, you assume it's from a dog. In China there is a 90% it came from a human."
Ahhh.... culture.
Post a Comment